Skip to content
Blog

First-time buyer guide

Is Buying a Home Actually Better Than Renting? I Ran the Numbers.

I sell real estate, so you'd expect me to say buy. I ran 30 years of numbers on a $250,000 Indy home instead, and renting and investing came out slightly ahead. Here's why I'd still look hard at buying.


Tan stucco duplex with a gambrel roof and two front entrances on a tree-lined street in Indianapolis

And the answer wasn't quite what I expected.

I sell real estate for a living, so you might expect me to tell you that buying a home is always better than renting.

But I don't actually believe that.

I've always been a believer that homeownership is one of the most accessible ways for everyday people to build wealth. But I also think we do ourselves a disservice when we reduce the conversation to "renting is throwing money away."

Because it's not that simple.

So I wanted to run some numbers.

What would happen if you rented a home for 30 years versus buying a $250,000 home here in Indianapolis? And what if, instead of buying, you invested the money you saved by renting?

Here's what I found.

First, let's look at the actual cost of buying.

Let's say you're currently renting for $1,500 a month.

You have an opportunity to buy a $250,000 home with a conventional loan, 3.5% down and a 7% interest rate on a 30-year mortgage.

Here's approximately what your monthly expenses would look like:

  • Mortgage principal and interest: $1,605
  • Property taxes: $208
  • Homeowners insurance: $142
  • Maintenance: $208
  • Mortgage insurance: $111

Total: $2,274 per month.

Chart comparing $1,500 a month to rent with $2,274 a month to own a $250,000 Indianapolis home with 3.5% down at a 7% mortgage rate

That's $774 more than you're currently spending on rent.

Not exactly an insignificant difference.

Now let's assume your rent increases by 3% every year. Meanwhile, your mortgage principal and interest stay fixed, although property taxes, insurance, and maintenance continue to increase. We'll also assume your mortgage insurance eventually falls off once you reach 20% equity under the applicable cancellation rules.

After 30 years, you'd have spent approximately:

Renting: $856,000

Owning: $919,000

That's roughly $63,000 more spent on homeownership, including your initial down payment.

But there's one pretty significant difference.

After 30 years of renting, you don't have a home to sell.

After 30 years of ownership, you do.

Here's where homeownership gets interesting.

Let's assume your $250,000 home appreciates by an average of 3% annually.

After 30 years, your home would be worth approximately $607,000.

Your mortgage is paid off, meaning you've built more than $600,000 in equity.

Even after accounting for the costs of selling, you'd walk away with approximately $570,000.

That's a pretty remarkable outcome from an initial down payment of just $8,750.

And it's one of the reasons I'm such a believer in homeownership.

You're not just making a monthly payment. A portion of that payment is going toward an asset you own, and over time, that asset has the potential to grow in value.

But there's another side to the equation.

What if you rented and invested the difference?

This is probably the most compelling argument for renting.

Remember that $774 monthly difference between renting and buying?

What if you invested it instead?

Let's say you earned a hypothetical 7% annual return and consistently invested whatever you saved by renting. You also invested the money you would have spent on a down payment and buying closing costs.

As rents increase, the amount you're able to invest shrinks. Eventually, renting actually becomes more expensive than owning, and you'd need to draw from that investment account to cover the difference.

Even accounting for that, after 30 years, you'd have approximately $599,000 invested under these assumptions.

Compare that to the homeowner's approximately $570,000 in net equity after selling costs.

The renter actually comes out slightly ahead.

Bar chart of projected assets after 30 years: about $599,000 for renting and investing versus about $570,000 for buying and building equity

Surprised?

I was a little.

Of course, that's assuming you faithfully invest the difference, earn the modeled returns, and don't touch that money for three decades. Actual market returns aren't guaranteed, and taxes could change the outcome.

But I think it's an important reminder that renting isn't inherently a bad financial decision, and buying isn't automatically a good one.

Your habits matter. The price you pay matters. The home you buy matters.

And perhaps most importantly, what you're trying to accomplish with your money matters.

But here's where I think the math and real life start to separate.

I have a hard time believing that most people would actually invest that $774 difference every single month for 30 years.

Could they? Absolutely.

Do some people have that kind of discipline? Of course.

But I think most of us, myself included, are pretty good at finding ways to spend whatever money is left over at the end of the month.

An extra dinner out. A nicer car. Another subscription. A vacation that costs a little more than we planned.

It's not that any of those things are inherently bad. It's just that money has a way of disappearing when we haven't given it a specific purpose.

And this is one of the most underrated financial benefits of homeownership.

Your mortgage creates a form of forced savings.

Every month, part of your mortgage payment goes toward paying down your principal balance. That's money you're effectively converting into equity in your home.

You don't have to remember to transfer it into an investment account. You don't have to decide whether to invest it or spend it.

It's built into the payment you're already obligated to make.

Now, I want to be clear. Not every dollar of your mortgage payment is building wealth. Interest, taxes, insurance, and maintenance are real expenses. And home equity isn't nearly as liquid as money sitting in an investment account.

But the principal you're paying down is reducing what you owe on an asset you own.

And over 30 years, that adds up.

I think there's something powerful about a financial system that doesn't rely entirely on your own discipline.

Sure, the renter who invests every spare dollar might outperform the homeowner on paper.

But what about the renter who invests half the difference? Or the one who intends to start investing next month and never quite gets around to it?

That's where the outcome starts to look pretty different.

The best financial strategy isn't always the one that produces the highest theoretical return. Sometimes it's the one you're most likely to actually follow.

And for a lot of people, I think homeownership provides exactly that kind of structure.

But I think there's something else missing from this comparison.

One of my biggest frustrations with the rent-versus-buy conversation is that we tend to evaluate our homes exclusively as financial assets.

And while I think we absolutely should understand the financial implications of buying, I don't think that's the whole story.

I own a home that's more than 100 years old here in Indianapolis.

There are plenty of days when I wonder what exactly I signed myself up for.

There's always something that needs to be fixed, replaced, painted, or improved.

But there's also something incredibly satisfying about taking ownership of a place and slowly making it your own.

I can renovate a room. Update the landscaping. Add a home gym. Change the layout to better accommodate my growing family.

I get to make decisions about the space where my family spends so much of our lives.

That matters to me.

And there are other benefits that don't show up on a spreadsheet.

There's the investment you make in your neighborhood. Getting to know your neighbors. Becoming a regular at your local coffee shop. Caring about what happens on your block because you have a personal stake in its future.

Now, none of those things are exclusive to homeowners. Renters can and absolutely do build meaningful connections to their communities.

But I do think ownership can create a different level of permanence and intentionality.

There's something about knowing you plan to be somewhere for a while that changes how you engage with that place.

And what about creating your own appreciation?

Here's another part of homeownership that gets overlooked.

You don't necessarily have to sit around and wait for your home's value to increase.

You can influence it.

Maybe you purchase a home with an unfinished basement and turn it into usable living space.

Maybe you improve a dated kitchen, add a bathroom, or make improvements that increase the property's functionality and appeal.

Not every renovation is going to return more than it costs. Some improvements are simply worth doing because they make your home more enjoyable.

But others can meaningfully increase the value of your property.

That's an opportunity most renters don't have.

And if you're intentional about the home you purchase, you may be able to create equity rather than simply wait for appreciation.

Your first home doesn't have to be your forever home.

Graphic showing a $250,000 first home, about $109,000 in equity after selling in 10 years, and a $400,000 next home

This is one of the ideas I wish more first-time buyers understood.

Let's go back to that $250,000 home.

Say you live there for 10 years.

Assuming 3% annual appreciation, your home would be worth roughly $336,000.

During that time, you've also been paying down your mortgage.

If you sold the home, paid off the remaining loan, and covered your selling expenses, you could walk away with approximately $109,000 in equity.

Now imagine putting that money toward a $400,000 home.

Instead of starting from scratch trying to save a down payment, you've got more than 25% of the purchase price ready to put down.

You've used your first home to help you get into your next one.

Now, moving into a more expensive house isn't automatically the financially optimal decision. You're taking on a new mortgage and increasing your housing costs.

But that's kind of my point.

Our housing decisions aren't exclusively about maximizing our net worth.

Maybe you started in a small two-bedroom home, but now you have kids and need more room.

Maybe you've gotten married, changed jobs, or discovered that your priorities have changed.

Your home can be part of that progression.

And the equity you've accumulated can give you options that would have been much harder to access otherwise.

You might even decide to keep your first home as a rental, assuming the numbers make sense, and begin building wealth through multiple properties.

There's no single path that works for everyone.

So, is buying actually better than renting?

I think the better question is: What do you want your housing decision to do for your life?

If you're renting well below what it would cost you to own, investing the difference, and enjoying the flexibility of moving whenever you want, renting might make a ton of sense.

If you're ready to establish roots, want greater control over your living space, and have the financial stability to take on the responsibilities of ownership, buying might be one of the best decisions you make.

And if your goal is to build long-term wealth, I think it's worth understanding how homeownership can help you accomplish that, particularly if you're willing to purchase something that isn't perfect and improve it over time.

There's a reason I enjoy helping people buy their first home.

It's not because I believe everyone needs to own property.

It's because I've seen what happens when people begin to think intentionally about where they live, what they can afford, and what they're trying to build.

The home itself is only part of the equation.

The bigger goal is to build a life worth coming home to.

And whether you're renting or buying, I think that's something worth being intentional about.


I'm Kyle, an Indianapolis Realtor with Roots Realty Co. I help people navigate buying their first home, explore house hacking, and find their place in Indianapolis.

Curious about where you might fit in Indy? Take my Indianapolis neighborhood quiz.

Financial examples are illustrative, not guarantees. The model uses 3% annual growth for rent, home appreciation, taxes, insurance, and maintenance, plus a hypothetical 7% investment return. It assumes conventional-style mortgage insurance can be canceled at the appropriate threshold. Individual financing, property expenses, taxes, transaction costs, and returns will vary.

Common questions

Is it cheaper to rent or buy a home in Indianapolis?

Renting is often cheaper upfront, but buying can build long-term wealth through mortgage paydown and home appreciation. The better option depends on your monthly budget, how long you plan to stay, and your financial goals.

How long should you live in a home before selling?

Generally, planning to stay at least five years is a good starting point. This gives you time to build equity and potentially benefit from appreciation while offsetting the costs of buying and selling.

Is buying a home worth it with a 7% mortgage rate?

Absolutely, it can be. Even at 7%, homeowners build equity through principal payments and potential appreciation. The key is finding a home you can comfortably afford today without relying on future refinancing or rising property values.

About the author

Kyle Hoffman smiling with arms crossed against a dark wood wall

Kyle Hoffman, REALTOR®, Roots Realty Co.

Licensed in Indiana, #RB23001739

I'm a proud Indianapolis native and a former high school Anatomy and Physiology teacher. Now I help people buy first homes and house hacks, one step at a time.

House hack quiz

Could house hacking fit your life?

A short quiz with options to explore, not a verdict.